Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
IL Panificio Pizzeria Downtown
Welcome to IL Panificio Pizzeria Downtown, a gem nestled in the heart of Sarasota at 1703 Main St. This charming pizzeria is not just another stop for pizza lovers; it’s a culinary experience that transports you straight to the vibrant streets of Little Italy. With a commitment to crafting the perfect New York-style pizza, IL Panificio stands out for its thin, crispy crust, rich tomato sauce, and the freshest toppings available.
Patrons rave about the deliciousness served at IL Panificio, with customers like D B appreciating the simplicity of a classic cheese pizza. For a mere $4.44, you can indulge in a slice that is perfectly proportioned alongside a refreshing Coke for just $7.77—a delightful and affordable option for a quick lunch during your busy workday. This cozy environment encourages you to savor each bite while you take a moment away from your hustle and bustle.
But what truly sets IL Panificio apart is not just the food; it's the exceptional service that accompanies it. Dusan Peric's experience of leaving personal devices behind only to find them safely held by the staff speaks volumes about their dedication to customer care. Such attentiveness makes for an inviting atmosphere where every visitor feels valued.
The pizzeria is also widely regarded as the best on the keys, with Mark Mulone affirming that while it may not be the cheapest, the quality and taste are unparalleled. A distinct highlight is their 21-inch ham and pineapple pizza, as noted by Joe T Woods, which touts a unique dough passed down through generations—over 100 years old! The meticulous five-day fermentation process yields a crust that is not only chewy but also adept at holding toppings without being greasy.
As you step into IL Panificio Pizzeria Downtown, the aroma of freshly baked bread fills the air, reminiscent of bustling Italian markets. Get ready to be captivated by the heartwarming ambiance and the memory-evoking flavors that will surely keep you coming back for more. Whether you're a local or just passing through Sarasota, this pizzeria should be a must-visit on your gastronomic journey.
For more information or to order, don't hesitate to give them a call at +1 941-366-5570. IL Panificio Pizzeria Downtown awaits to serve you the pizza of your dreams!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Very delicious pizza. I looooove thin style pizza. 4.44 for a delicious slice of cheese pizza & with a coke was 7.77. Perfect little lunch while working. Highly recommend. Might try a different flavor of pizza next time but honestly might just get the cheese pizza again as it was perfect. ”
“ Not only is this pizza excellent but the staff is amazing.!!! Left my devices on the table. They found it-and held it for me until I made it back a few hours later. Thanks guys! ”
“ Best pizza on the key. Not cheap but the best. Rip fire is also good for individual pizzas with any topping combinations. A couple of our door tables but your looking at the parking area. ”
“ This cozy, pizzeria in the heart of downtown Sarasota, serves up that classic New York style pie. Thin, crispy crust, fresh tomato sauce, and the freshest toppings! Il Panificio pizza takes you back in time to little Italy, in the days when the smell of fresh bread filled the air, market street was bustling with vibrant Italian music and heartfelt conversations. Always a Sarasota favorite, IL Panificio Pizzeria is a place you'll make a favorite stop for pizza!! ”
“ I’ll Pacifico has the best New York style pizza I have ever tasted. Their thin dough comes from the owners grandmother and is over 100 years old and is light and thin and holds the toppings perfectly. My favorite is the 21 inch ham and pineapple pie. I like the saltiness of the ham and the sweetness of the pineapple. Their dough has a very unique taste and I’m told the fermentation process is about 5 days and they make their dough twice a week for both locations. The meats and cheese they use is top notch. And the pizza is not overtly greasy. The crust has a nice chewy texture and you’ll find no big dough bubbles in the crust when baked. Try their pizza you’ll love it and you’ll come back for more. Be sure to get the 21 inch size so you have leftovers. It reheats nicely and is good the next day. ”
“ Without a doubt this is my favorite pizza in Sarasota! The thin crust is so amazing. If you only try one new place this month COME HERE! You won’t be disappointed. Fast friendly service with amazing consistent quality ”
“ Might not be the best pizza I've ever had- but it is definitely one of the better ones. Truly adhering to the New York style pizza making tradition, this is a very thin pie, but one that manages to be both crunchy and chewy, as opposed to just cracker like. I ordered takeout and got the 3 cheese, with the addition of lump ricotta taking the flavor of the pizza to another creamy level. The sauce was good,and it's the kind of pizza where the crust is possibly the best part, as opposed to an afterthought. Definitely deserves the fanfare it has gotten on review sites and notably from Dave Portnoy. ”
“ The pizza here is delicious. I actually called the Main St. location after calling 5 different pizza places because I really needed curbside pickup, as I had two babies in the car. The gentleman who picked up the phone was so pleasant and offered to bring it out for me. I am so grateful for him and I appreciate that he went above and beyond. I unfortunately didn’t get his name but this happened yesterday around 1pm. ”